Olde Silver Tavern Menu
36 items in 3 sections · $5.00 – $10.00 · Restaurant in Manalapan Township, NJ
Olde Silver Tavern’s menu lists 36 dishes and drinks, grouped into Drink Local, Features| On Tap, and Bottled Beer. Prices range from $5.00 to $10.00, and a typical item costs about $7.00. Popular choices include Asbury Park Blonde Ale, Allagash White, Amstel Light, Cape May Coastal Evacuation, and Blue Moon.
Drink Local 8
- Asbury Park Blonde Ale$7.00
This light bodied European style lager features Pilsner Malt and German Noble hops of the highest quality. Also pairs well with the album by Mr. Ocean. ABV 4.8%
- Cape May Coastal Evacuation$7.00
This West Coast-style Double IPA by Cape May Brewing Co. is as big and bold as hurricane season itself, with a Centennial-forward, brazen blend of hops serving up hints of orange citrus and honeydew melon. ABV: 8.0%
- Carton 077XX$7.00
Dank green resinous hops popping over orange, mango and papaya aromas, with just enough sweetness of body to make the long finish a pleasure to have around. ABV: 7.8% Atlantic Highlands, NJ
- Icarus Yacht Juice$8.00
North East style IPA filled with Citra, Mosaic, and Columbus leaving it with a combination of citrus and dank aroma and flavor. ABV: 8% Lakewood, NJ
- Kane Head High$7.00
Head High is an American-style IPA that's all about the hops; noticeable grapefruit flavor with aromas of citrus, tropical fruits, and pine with a straw color, foamy head, and crisp flavor. ABV: 6.6% Ocean Township, NJ
- Twin Lights Lager$6.00
4.8% German style Pilsner Tinton Falls, NJ
- Kane Sneakbox$7.00
5.4% American Pale Ale Ocean Township, NJ
- Tall Oaks Harvest$8.00
5.8% Marzen Lager, Farmingdale, NJ
Features| On Tap 12
- Allagash White$7.00
5.2% Belgian Style Wheat Beer
- Blue Moon$6.00
5.4% Belgian Style Wheat Ale
- Guinness$8.00
4.2% Dry Stout
- Kona Big Wave$7.00
4.4% Golden Ale
- Miller Lite$5.00
4.2% American Pilsner
- Stella Artois$6.00
5% Belgian Lager
- Yuengling$5.00
4.2% American Lager
- New Belgium Voodoo Ranger$7.00
7.0% Hazy IPO
- Sam Adams Octoberfest$7.00
5.3% Marzen
- Down East Original Blend$7.00
5.1 % unfiltered Craft Cidar
- Schlafly Pumpkin Ale$6.00
8% Seasonal Pumpkin Beer
- Kostritizer Schwarzbier$6.00
4.8% German Black Beer
Bottled Beer 16
- Amstel Light$6.00
- Budweiser$5.00
- Bud Light$5.00
- Coors Light$5.00
- Corona Extra$6.00
- Corona Premiere$6.00
- Dos Equis$6.00
- Heineken$6.00
- Heineken Light$6.00
- Michelob Ultra$5.00
- Michelob Ultra Zero$5.00
- White Claw Black Cherry$9.00
- High Noon$10.00
pineapple, peach, watermelon
- Surf Side$10.00
ice tea, ice tea & lemonade, lemonade
- Talkhouse$9.00
blood orange tequila selzer
- Suncruiser$9.00
How these prices compare
Based on 109 menus with 8,058 priced items from restaurants in New Jersey, the median menu item costs $14.15, and half of all items are priced between $8.00 and $20.00.
At Olde Silver Tavern the median listed price is $7.00, lower than the typical $14.15 for restaurants in New Jersey.
| Item | On menus | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| French Fries | 25% | $6.45 |
| Caesar Salad | 21% | $12.00 |
| Onion Rings | 16% | $8.70 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | 16% | $12.00 |
| Coffee | 15% | $3.00 |
| Fried Calamari | 13% | $16.27 |
Typical prices are calculated from 109 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.